EA Sports' "Madden NFL 24" will be released on Aug. 18, but its initial player ratings are now out. The Colts had two players with top-10 ratings at their respective positions:
The six highest-rated Colts:
- Quenton Nelson (92)
- Jonathan Taylor (89)
- DeForest Buckner (86)
- Shaquille Leonard (86)
- Michael Pittman Jr. (85)
- Grover Stewart (85)
The Colts' highest speed ratings:
- Jonathan Taylor (94)
- Tony Brown (93)
- Darius Rush (93)
- Ashton Dulin (93)
- Vyncint Smith (92)
- Breshad Perriman (92)
- Nick Cross (92)
- Alec Pierce (92)
- Isaiah McKenzie (92)
The Colts' highest strength ratings:
- Quenton Nelson (97)
- Braden Smith (92)
- Grover Stewart (91)
- DeForest Buckner (90)
- Bernhard Raimann (90)
Here's the full list of ratings (not every player on the Colts' 90-man roster is included; long snapper Luke Rhodes is listed as a tight end).
| Player | Madden Position | Overall Rating |
|---|---|---|
| Adetomiwa Adebawore | RE | 66 |
| McTelvin Agim | RE | 67 |
| Mo Alie-Cox | TE | 73 |
| Darrell Baker Jr. | CB | 63 |
| Henry Black | FS | 68 |
| Julian Blackmon | FS | 75 |
| JuJu Brents | CB | 74 |
| Pharaoh Brown | TE | 70 |
| Tony Brown | CB | 69 |
| Taven Bryan | DT | 70 |
| DeForest Buckner | DT | 86 |
| Nick Cross | SS | 71 |
| Trevor Denbow | SS | 62 |
| JoJo Domann | MLB | 63 |
| Josh Downs | WR | 71 |
| Ashton Dulin | WR | 72 |
| Samson Ebukam | RE | 76 |
| Sam Ehlinger | QB | 56 |
| Emil Ekiyor | RG | 62 |
| Dallis Flowers | CB | 62 |
| Zaire Franklin | ROLB | 73 |
| Blake Freeland | RT | 69 |
| Wesley French | C | 56 |
| Will Fries | RG | 65 |
| Jake Funk | HB | 65 |
| Matt Gay | K | 80 |
| Kylen Granson | TE | 68 |
| Arlington Hambright | LG | 59 |
| Evan Hull | HB | 66 |
| Deon Jackson | HB | 64 |
| Eric Johnson II | DT | 64 |
| Jaylon Jones | CB | 65 |
| Khalid Kareem | RE | 67 |
| Ryan Kelly | C | 77 |
| Titus Leo | RE | 67 |
| Shaquille Leonard | LOLB | 86 |
| Tyquan Lewis | LE | 72 |
| Will Mallory | TE | 63 |
| Cameron McGrone | LOLB | 65 |
| Isaiah McKenzie | WR | 77 |
| Gardner Minshew II | QB | 67 |
| Kenny Moore II | CB | 84 |
| Zack Moss | RB | 72 |
| Quenton Nelson | LG | 92 |
| Dayo Odeyingbo | LE | 72 |
| Andrew Ogletree | TE | 62 |
| Kwity Paye | LE | 77 |
| Breshad Perriman | WR | 70 |
| Alec Pierce | WR | 74 |
| Danny Pinter | RG | 65 |
| Michael Pittman Jr. | WR | 85 |
| Bernhard Raimann | LT | 74 |
| Luke Rhodes | TE* | 31 |
| Anthony Richardson | QB | 70 |
| Darius Rush | CB | 69 |
| Rigoberto Sanchez | P | 76 |
| Daniel Scott** | SS | 68 |
| Dakoda Shepley | C | 50 |
| Braden Smith | RT | 82 |
| Kaden Smith | TE | 62 |
| Vyncint Smith | WR | 67 |
| EJ Speed | LOLB | 70 |
| Grover Stewart | DT | 85 |
| Mike Strachan | WR | 65 |
| Grant Stuard | ROLB | 64 |
| Jonathan Taylor | HB | 89 |
| Rodney Thomas II | FS | 70 |
| Kevin Toliver II | CB | 67 |
| Malik Turner | WR | 68 |
| Juwann Winfree | WR | 67 |
| Jake Witt | LT | 61 |
| Jelani Woods | TE | 70 |
**The Colts placed Scott, a 2023 fifth-round pick, on injured reserve in June. He will not play this season.
