Carlie Irsay-Gordon is in her 12th season as vice chair/owner. She joined the Colts as vice president in 2008 and, along with sisters Casey Foyt and Kalen Jackson, represents the next generation of ownership of the club. Raised in and around the organization, Irsay-Gordon interned with the Colts football operations and marketing departments while pursuing her undergraduate degree in religious studies from Skidmore College. She is involved in all aspects of the organization, with an emphasis on football operations and the team's digital, social media, content and production operations.

Irsay-Gordon is a member of the NFL's Media Owned & Operated Committee, which oversees the NFL Network, NFL.com, NFL Mobile and other league owned media properties. As the only active female member of the committee, she is responsible for setting strategies and policy related to traditional and digital media initiatives across the NFL and its clubs. Irsay-Gordon is also a member of the NFL's Security & Fan Conduct Committee and has represented the Colts at NFL Owners' Meetings since 2004. She also serves on the board of the NFl Player Care Foundation, which aims to improve the quality of life for retired players. Irsay-Gordon is involved in the Indianapolis community, serving on the boards of Visit Indy, the citys convention and tourism bureau and Park Tudor School. She also served as co-chair of the Indy Championships Fund, which was charged with raising private dollars to host the 2021 NCAA Men's Basketball Tournament, the 2022 College Football Playoffs Championship game and the upcoming 2024 NBA All-Star Game. Irsay-Gordon resides in Indianapolis with her husband, Zach Gordon, and three children.